Gold Glove Awards
| Season | Pitcher | Catcher | First Base | Second Base | Third Base | Shortstop | Outfield | Outfield | Outfield | Season |
| 2013 #29 | Clayton Kershaw | Matt Wieters | Mark Teixeira (7) | Darwin Barney | Adrian Beltre (3) | Jimmy Rollins (5) | Adam Jones | Andrew McCutchen | Cameron Maybin (2) | 2013 #29 |
| 2012 #28 | Dan Haren (2) | Yadier Molina (3) | C. Kotchman (2) | Ben Zobrist | Jack Hannahan (2) | Troy Tulowitzki | Matt Kemp (4) | Cameron Maybin | Jacoby Ellsbury | 2012 #28 |
| 2012 #27 | Tim Stauffer | Yadier Molina (2) | Mark Teixeira (6) | Brandon Phillips (4) | Jack Hannahan | Jimmy Rollins (4) | Matt Kemp (3) | Michael Bourn (3) | Shane Victorino (2) | 2012 #27 |
| 2011 #26 | Roy Halladay | Yadier Molina | Mark Teixeira (5) | Brandon Phillips (3) | Bill Monroe | Aramis Ramirez | Michael Bourn (2) | Andres Torres (2) | Angel Pagan | 2011 #26 |
| 2011 #25 | Jonathan Sanchez | Carlos Ruiz | Albert Pujols (2) | Robinson Cano | Scott Rolen (8) | Elvis Andrus | Dexter Fowler | Chris Young | Andres Torres | 2011 #25 |
| 2010 #24 | Mark Buehrle (2) | Joe Mauer (2) | Mark Teixeira (4) | Aaron Hill (2) | Scott Rolen (7) | Jimmy Rollins (3) | Matt Kemp (2) | Oscar Charleston | Tori Hunter (12) | 2010 #24 |
| 2010 #23 | Javier Vazquez | Gerald Laird | Adrian Gonzalez (2) | Aaron Hill | Scott Rolen (6) | Jimmy Rollins (2) | Matt Kemp | Tori Hunter (11) | Michael Bourn | 2010 #23 |
| 2009 #22 | Dan Haren | Ray Schalk | Adrian Gonzalez | A. Iwamura (2) | Adrian Beltre (2) | Miguel Tejada | Mike Cameron (3) | Carlos Beltran (5) | Tori Hunter (10) | 2009 #22 |
| 2009 #21 | Mark Buehrle | Rod Barajas | Casey Kotchman | Akinori Iwamura | Adrian Beltre | Jimmy Rollins | Shane Victorino | Carlos Bentran (4) | Torii Hunter (9) | 2009 #21 |
| 2008 #20 | D. Matsuzaka (2) | Roger Bresnahan | Derek Lee | Brandon Phillips (2) | Jimmy Collins | Omar Vizquel (10) | Ichiro Suzuki (8) | Vernon Wells (2) | Torii Hunter (8) | 2008 #20 |
| 2008 #19 | Daisuke Matsuzaka | Russell Martin | Mark Teixeira (3) | Brandon Phillips | Aramis Ramirez | Orlando Cabrera | Torii Hunter (7) | Grady Sizemore | Ichiro Suzuki (7) | 2008 #19 |
| 2007 #18 | Jason Schmidt | Ramon Hernandez | Albert Pujols | Mark Grudzielanek | Mike Lowell (4) | Omar Vizquel (9) | Vernon Wells | Carlos Beltran (3) | Andruw Jones (10) | 2007 #18 |
| 2007 #17 | Jeff Suppan | Paul Lo Duca | Mark Teixeira (2) | Tadahito Iguchi | Mike Lowell (3) | Omar Vizquel (8) | Carlos Beltran (2) | Torii Hunter (6) | Andruw Jones (9) | 2007 #17 |
| 2006 #16 | Dizzy Dean | Joe Mauer | Mark Teixeira | Luis Castillo (4) | Alex Rodriguez (3) | Jack Wilson (2) | Andruw Jones (8) | Ichiro Suzuki (6) | Aaron Rowand | 2006 #16 |
| 2006 #15 | Tom Glavine (3) | Damian Miller | Todd Helton (4) | Adam Kennedy | Alex Rodriguez (2) | Jack Wilson | Jim Edmonds (3) | Andruw Jones (7) | Ichiro Suzuki (5) | 2006 #15 |
| 2005 #14 | Kenny Rogers | Jorge Posada | Todd Helton (3) | Orlando Hudson | Scott Rolen (5) | Cesar Izturis (2) | Steve Finley (5) | Larry Doby | Carlos Beltran | 2005 #14 |
| 2005 #13 | Brad Radke | Mike Lieberthal | Todd Helton (2) | Luis Castillo (3) | Vinny Castillo | Cesar Izturis | Andruw Jones (6) | Torii Hunter (5) | Ichiro Suzuki (4) | 2005 #13 |
| 2004 #12 | Livan Hernandez | Mike Matheny (2) | Derrek Lee | Luis Castillo (2) | Mike Lowell (2) | Hughie Jennings | Andruw Jones (5) | Torii Hunter (4) | Mike Cameron (2) | 2004 #12 |
| 2004 #11 | Danny Graves | Mike Matheny | John Olerud (5) | Luis Castillo | Scott Rolen (4) | Alex Rodriguez | Jim Edmonds (2) | Ichiro Suzuki (3) | Torii Hunter (3) | 2004 #11 |
| 2003 #10 | Bob Feller | A.J. Pierzynski | John Olerud (4) | Joe Morgan | Craig Counsell | Omar Vizquel (7) | Andruw Jones (4) | Duke Snider | Darin Erstad (4) | 2003 #10 |
| 2003 #9 | Tomo Ohka | Dan Wilson (2) | Todd Helton | Bret Boone | Mike Lowell | Omar Vizquel (6) | Torii Hunter (2) | Darin Erstad (3) | Steve Finley (5) | 2003 #9 |
| 2002 #8 | Bob Gibson | Brad Ausmus (2) | J.T. Snow (2) | Fernando Vina | Eric Chavez | Omar Vizquel (5) | Ty Cobb | Ichiro Suzuki (2) | Tris Speaker | 2002 #8 |
| 2002 #7 | Jon Lieber | Dan Wilson | John Olerud (3) | Roberto Alomar (4) | Scott Rolen (3) | Omar Vizquel (4) | Ichiro Suzuki | Torii Hunter | Mike Cameron | 2002 #7 |
| 2001 #6 | Tom Glavine (2) | Henry Blanco | John Olerud (2) | Edgardo Alfonso (2) | Travis Fryman | Omar Vizquel (3) | Steve Finley (4) | Andruw Jones (3) | Darin Erstad (2) | 2001 #6 |
| 2001 #5 | Tom Glavine | Brad Ausmus | J.T. Snow | Edgardo Alfonso | Scott Rolen (2) | Omar Vizquel (2) | Andruw Jones (2) | Darin Erstad | Steve Finley (3) | 2001 #5 |
| 2000 #4 | Alex Fernandez | Ivan Rodriguez (2) | Mark Grace | Roberto Alomar (3) | Robin Ventura (2) | Derek Jeter (3) | Shawn Green | Steve Finley (2) | Jim Edmonds | 2000 #4 |
| 2000 #3 | Shane Reynolds | Ivan Rodriguez | Rafael Palmeiro | Pokey Reese | Robin Ventura | Derek Jeter (2) | Steve Finley | Ken Griffey, Jr. (2) | Larry Walker | 2000 #3 |
| 1999 #2 | Greg Maddux | Joe Girardi | John Olerud | Roberto Alomar (2) | Jeff Cirillo | Omar Vizquel | Andruw Jones | Bernie Williams (2) | Ken Griffey, Jr. | 1999 #2 |
| 1999 #1 | n/a | Charles Johnson | Jeff Bagwell | Roberto Alomar | Scott Rolen | Derek Jeter | Bernie Williams | Barry Bonds | Ray Lankford | 1999 #1 |
| Season | Pitcher | Catcher | First Base | Second Base | Third Base | Shortstop | Outfield | Outfield | Outfield | Season |